Esther - Deeper Into The Story
The book of Esther is a wonderfully crafted story of God’s hand at work. At every level, it yields insight into the nature of God and humanity. The story is a delight even at face value, but as one digs, greater treasures appear. Oddities in the story function as clues, leading to discoveries of things that are not as they seem…
The following material is mainly from Rabbi David Fohrman’s The Queen You Thought You Knew, along with some references to Genesis: A Parsha Companion. Fohrman is also founder of AlephBeta.org.
The book of Esther explores the themes of reversal, hiddenness, power, identity, and what it means for the Jews to be “saved” in a world that could care less about God.
The book is renowned for not mentioning God’s name. Yet the Jewish characters in the story give every indication of a deep and sophisticated understanding of their story as recorded in Torah and the Prophets. In a very real way, they rely upon their knowledge of God’s word to guide them to victory in the face of grave threats to their very existence.
So much to cover! So many questions! Where to begin? Let’s first put some of the questions out there, and then work through the story, dealing with them as we go.
(By the way: If working through Fohrman’s book, he uses “Megillah” without explanation; presumably his Jewish audience does not need one. A “megillah” is a generic Hebrew word for scroll. “The Megillah”, capitalized, is the conventional Jewish name for Megillat Esther (מְגִלַּת אֶסְתֵּר), “the Scroll of Esther”, whose English name is “The Book of Esther”).
Questions
QUESTION: Why does the Megillah (the “Scroll of Esther”) last so long?
After Haman was dealt with in chapter 7, it seems that the story could be quickly wrapped up: “After Haman was hanged, the Jews killed their enemies. Mordecai and Esther proclaimed that the victory be memorialized as Purim, and everyone lived happily ever after.”
But The Megillah continues for another three chapters! What appears to be the story’s climax is in fact not its climax.
QUESTION: Why is the holiday called “Purim”? (10:23-32)
In Ancient Persian and Aramaic, ‘pur’ means ’lot’, which Haman cast in order to determine the date of the planned genocide (Esther 3:7).
Why name a holiday after the device your enemy used to try to kill you? Why name it after an instrument of blind chance, rather than a symbol of faith?
QUESTION: Why make so much of the king’s majesty in chapter 1?
On the surface of it, this information seems extraneous to the apparent main point of the story–the Jews’ miraculous deliverance.
QUESTION: Why did the king attempt to parade his wife, Vashti, before drunken men?
What kind of scene would it have been, to be paraded (probably naked) before a crowd of drunken guests–who just happened to include the senior leadership of all Persia? (1:11) Wasn’t Vashti justified in refusing such a vulgar command?
QUESTION: Why make so much of Mordecai’s heritage and his rise?
- Mordecai was son of Yair, son of Kish; he was from the tribe of Benjamin (2:5), and a co-descendant with Saul.
- He went out in the streets dressed in royal blue robes; the city of Susa erupted in joy (8:15)
- Mordecai was 2nd in charge, great among the Jews, pleasing to “most” of his brethren (10:3)
All this seems beside the point of Purim, the miraculous salvation of the Jews.
QUESTION: Why does Mordecai assert that Esther’s help is not essential to the Jews’ deliverance? And how exactly would Esther and her father’s house be destroyed if she does not act?
Mordecai seemed very confident that deliverance for the Jews would happen, in spite of the apparent hopelessness of the crisis. He was also oddly sure that her father’s house specifically would bear the consequences of her inaction, in contrast to deliverance for the rest of the Jews.
QUESTION: Why didn’t Esther immediately ask the king for help with the decree against her people?
Esther asks instead to first throw a banquet–and then another. Although the king appears to go along with it, it’s difficult to see how Esther intended to advance her cause by exercising hospitality. We know that Haman met his downfall at the second banquet, but was this really Esther’s plan all along–serve a couple of meals, and then accuse Haman? Why did the king react so strongly, so readily “swallowing whole” Esther’s finger-pointing at his top official–even before he turned around and caught Haman falling on Esther’s couch, begging for his life? Something seems off, or at least missing. Without giving too much away…was the king somehow already primed to respond negatively to Haman? If so, how would this have happened?
QUESTION: Why does Esther weep before the king only after the death of Haman?
Why not much earlier? Why did not Esther weep and plead when she was first admitted to the king’s presence? Or even at the banquet, when revealing Haman as the villain? Only after Haman is dead does Esther dramatically throw herself at the king’s feet, weeping, pleading for mercy, begging the king to overturn Haman’s genocidal decree. Haman is already dead, and Mordecai already has the king’s signet ring. What makes her so urgent that she now displays such over-the-top emotion?
Why didn’t the Jews take plunder?
This, in spite of Mordecai’s decree explicitly saying that they COULD! Why authorize something he knows the Jews are not going to do?
Diving Into The Story
The focus on the king’s majesty
Esther’s king, likely Ahasuerus, may well be the same as the fourth king mentioned in Daniel who was
“far richer than all the others. When he has gained power by his wealth, he will stir up everyone against the kingdom of Greece.” (Daniel 11:2)
If so, the celebration wasn’t merely about the king having an outsized taste for partying. Ahasuerus was in fact in the middle of gathering support for an epic military campaign, which included “gaining power by his wealth”.
This would explain why
…for all his nobles and officials…the military leaders of Persia and Media…For a full 180 days, he displayed the vast wealth of his kingdom and the splendor and glory of his majesty." (Esther 1:3-4).
Note the explicit reference to “military leaders”.
The king was ruling over a vast, recently conquered empire still getting accustomed to being Persian. Media and Persia had defeated Babylon in the not-too-recent past; gathering support for his ambition was a major task.
The king’s intent for Vashti’s appearance
Although jarring to modern western sensibilities, the king’s purpose was much deeper and quite different than it may appear to readers.
In the scenario just described–of gathering support for a grand military campaign–Vashti’s appearance before the king’s gathered audience was critical. She was to be the culmination of the king’s extravagant presentation of New Persia to 127 far-flung, only marginally unified provinces. As Mother Persia, the queen’s role was to epitomize the beauty and grace of Persia, embodied in her own beauty and grace–the beauty and grace of their queen. The cabinet-level delegation sent to fetch Vashti served to reinforce the significance of her appearance as a high-level affair of state.
Yes, the king was at least somewhat drunk, and yes, Vashti’s repugnance to being objectified was absolutely valid. However, as Mother Persia, Vashti was intended by the king to function as a living symbol of the king’s empire and rule: a unifying, tangible focus for inspiring pride in being Persian. She was to express Persia’s greatness.
We in the United States today are not unfamiliar with this idea. Consider Lady Liberty, rising above New York Harbor, and the inscription at her base:
The New Colossus
Not like the brazen giant of greek fame,
with conquering limbs astride from land to land:
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
A mighty woman with a torch,
whose flame is the imprisoned lightning,
and her name mother of exiles.
From her beacon-hand glows world-wide welcome:
Her mild eyes command the
air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.
"Keep ancient lands, you storied pomp!"
cries she with silent lips.
"Give me your tired, your poor,
your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
the wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me.
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"
Follow this train of thought beyond Vashti for a moment, to the king’s attraction to Esther as Vashti’s replacement. Part of what might have made Esther so pleasing to the king could have been her very refusal to reveal her background–for surely he would have asked. For the king, she became exactly who he needed her to be: an utterly stateless girl who transcended whatever local or provincial identity fate had bequeathed her.
How then might the king react if Esther were to suddenly reveal an intense ethnic affiliation?
QUESTION: Which “him”?
Let us fast-forward in the story to the point where the king has extended his scepter, and Esther is responding to the king’s question and generous offer…
If I have found favor in your eyes, let the king and Haman come today to a banquet I have prepared for him. (5:4)
The Hebrew text says “…prepared for him”. Which “him” is it–the king or Haman? Many translations attempt to go ahead and resolve this ambiguity by substituting “prepared for the king”. But Esther meant exactly what she said.
Esther has planted the seed of an very dangerous idea in the king’s mind: she is insinuating, without quite saying it, that something is going on between her and Haman. (Forhman credits this analysis to Rashi, “grandfather of the medieval commentators”.)
Why would she do this? The next banquet, Esther says, is for “them”. BOTH of them??? Now the king is REALLY wondering, What is going on? No wonder the king couldn’t sleep that night!
As fate would have it, two men could not sleep that night.
From here onward, Haman demonstrates a complete inability to “read the room”–a blindness that would cost him his life.
When Haman comes home from the first banquet, he sees Mordecai, which provoked him to tip his hand. He had told the king that it was about a people (3:6), but now his actions reveal that it really was personal after all; it was all about Mordecai.
Haman’s wife counsels Haman to go to the king in the morning. But unfortunately for him, he just can’t wait ’til morning. He goes in the middle of the night to the king–who just happens to be awake, quite possibly because he is wondering whether Haman has been cheating with his wife.
As Haman cluelessly expounds on the man the king wants to honor, he refers to personal articles of the king–a terrible blunder, prompting the king to wonder even more: Does Haman’s fascination with “that which the king has used” extend further…even to the king’s wife? If the king was already wondering whether Haman was after Esther, Haman’s words only reinforce and deepen his suspicions.
Continuing in his self-obsessed presumption, Haman used the word “king” six times, and recommended that the royal crown be placed on his head. All of Haman’s references to the king’s crown and personal articles–which clearly Haman himself was expecting to wear–further fueled suspicion. The king could be excused for thinking, “Not only does Haman want my wife, he also wants my position!”
At face value, it seems strange that the king would select Haman to personally lead Mordecai through the streets. But in the context of what had transpired already, the king is very likely thinking Haman needs to be taken down a few notches.
So by the time of the 2nd banquet, Haman is suddenly extremely vulnerable. However, Esther doesn’t yet know how wildly successful her strategy has become. She is playing with fire on two fronts:
- The “Mother Persia” liability - if she throws in her lot with her people, she risks being seen as a fake or even a national traitor.
- The adulteress liability - If the king decides she is fooling around, she will be seen as personally betraying him.
Either of these charges would result in her execution. She must somehow divert the deadly momentum of the king’s fear and potential anger, so that it misses her and lands on Haman.
Esther positions the king as her personal hero: “give me my life!” (7:3) She mentions danger to her own life before her nation’s life, delivering immediate shock value from the king’s perspective. The news that she is a Jew has been drowned out by the explosive revelation that someone is out to kill the queen.
By casting Haman’s decree as one that threatens her own life, Esther avoids showing herself disloyal to the “Mother Persia” vision, and portrays Haman himself as the disloyal one–he is the one who won’t accept her as queen of all Persia; he is the one stuck in a tribal mindset.
“Haman is trying to kill me, along with all other Jews, because of nothing more than our ethnic identity. He is so caught up in tagging people by group, race, ethnicity, that he can’t look past my provincial roots to see me for the queen that I am, the queen you want me to be!”
The king gets to be her knight in shining armor, because “Haman is trying to take me away from you!”
In the heat of the moment, the king apparently doesn’t stop to think that Esther’s claim–that Haman is out to personally take her life–is not even close to 100% true. Haman didn’t even know Esther was a Jew until just that moment! The notion that Haman meant personal harm to her is ridiculous.
Unfortunately for Esther, the king goes into the garden to think things over. Esther is now in a vulnerable position. She needs the king to act impetuously, but now he’s in danger of seeing through her portrayal.
Haman however, made irrational by fear, continues to blunder fatally–this time by falling on Esther’s couch. When the king sees this, he too reacts irrationally and emotionally, speaking from his heart and not his mind. The sense of the text is that the king’s words just slip out, without the king even consciously thinking about what he was saying:
So, you would even conquer the queen while I am yet in the house!
Rationally, it makes no sense that Haman would try to seduce the queen if he’s trying to kill her. But the scene before the king’s eyes ignites all the suspicions that kept him awake the night before.
And now, the king’s eunuch delivers the final blow: “There’s a gallows that Haman had made for Mordecai…” (7:9) Twisting the knife, he adds “(the same Mordecai) who spoke up to help the king.” And so Haman meets his end.
The rest of the story
Now we come to the reason for the next 3 chapters. Haman is dead, but the decree is alive and well. Haman may yet celebrate the demise of the Jews, albeit from his grave.
All the king’s gifts - the elevation of Mordecai to the royal court, the handover of Haman’s property to Esther, and the use of the king’s signet ring - are for naught. The king does not reverse the decree. As far as his interests are concerned, everything has been taken care of:
- My wife is safe, and so is my crown.
- My enemy is dead.
- Mordecai has been repaid for his loyalty.
- All is good.
Esther’s plan has failed!
Now she must pursue a new plan by making a direct plea, again risking all. This moment is more dangerous for her than all the others. The notion of protecting a particular people from oppression was nowhere on the king’s radar and did not twitch his moral compass in the slightest. Somehow, Esther had to stir the king to act, while hopefully not dying in the process.
NOW she employs tears:
Esther again pleaded with the king, falling at his feet and weeping. She beseeched him to revoke the evil of Haman the Agagite, the plots he had plotted against the Jews. The king lifted his scepter and Esther got up and stood before the king.
The king lets her live, but now he is annoyed. There is a sense that Esther is pushing him too far. He allows them to write another decree favorable to Jews, but Haman’s original horrific decree against the Jews still stands; it will not be revoked, because
“no document written in the king’s name and sealed with his signet ring can be revoked”.
In other words, “Write whatever you want, but that decree is not going away.” Mordecai has a license to write in the king’s name, but–at least the way the king sees it–that license is useless for Esther’s purposes.
Esther exits the king’s presence alive, but she has again failed. What now?
The text jumps straight to describing in detail the implementation of the counter-decree. But in reality, between the time that Esther left the king’s presence and the time that couriers sped away to all the provinces, much strategizing took place.
The text makes much of royal involvement: “the royal secretaries”, “the name of King Xerxes”, “the king’s signet ring”, “fast horses bred especially for the king”, “the king’s edict”, “all the provinces of King Xerxes”, “The couriers…spurred on by the king’s command”.
The appearance to the populace was that the king himself was behind the decree. But was he?
We have already seen that the king was supremely uninterested in the fate of the Jews. He gave permission for Mordecai to act “as seems best to you”, but did not himself actually lift a finger. What was actually happening?
Esther and Mordecai’s new plan was a war of public relations. Mordecai’s counter-decree was about the Jews, but the audience was the “officials, the governors, and princes of the … 127 provinces” He appealed to their sense of self-preservation, making it seem like the king was leaning toward siding with the Jews.
Mordecai knew that any subsequent decree on the matter of the Jews would be weighed against the first decree, as provincial officials tried to get a sense of the Palace’s real position. The second decree must go toe-to-toe with the first. It must be every bit as violent and bloodthirsty as the first.
However, at most the two decrees could only cancel each other out. Some governors would honor the first, some would honor the second. More would be needed to tip the balance.
And Mordecai went out from before the king in royal dress, wearing turquoise and white robes, with a big golden crown…and the city of Susa erupted in happiness (8:15)
Wait, hold on…no victory had yet happened! The victory parade came BEFORE the war, and well BEFORE the actual victory. It was a spectacle designed for the mid-level officials throughout the 127 provinces–a psychological warfare campaign.
Mordecai used the tools available to him to create out of thin air the illusion that the palace was backing the Jews, when in reality, the king was at best indifferent to their fate.
This time, the deception worked: The barometer of public perception shifted in favor of the Jews: Mordecai’s fame and reputation grew, and people converted to Judaism for fear of the Jews…and all BEFORE the war happened.
But one hurdle remained: When the decrees took effect and the fighting began, the king was not happy about the reports of Jewish vigilantism. If the king were to stop things now, it would have been disastrous for the Jews; it would be seen as validating the original decree. Esther had to be careful…
If it pleases the king, give tomorrow to the Jews of Susa to continue what they’ve done today, and let the ten sons of Haman be hanged on the gallows. (9:33)
Haman’s sons had already been killed. Why hang people who were already dead? Because it put the final touches on the grand deception, making it seem as if the palace was unwavering in its support of the Jews.
In the end, the bluff worked: The public relations campaign was successful. Mordecai and Esther were able to fabricate the impression that the palace actually cared about the welfare of the Jews, swaying the governments of the 127 provinces to align themselves with Jewish fortunes.
And the nature of that campaign points toward the crux of the entire book of Esther, as does the name of the holiday: Purim.
Although “Purim” is commonly understood as derived from “Pur”, a word for the “lot” which Haman cast, the meaning of “Purim” actually reflects not the whim of the adversary nor random chance, but an unseen facet of a rather obscure passage in the Torah.
Purim: Annulling by Affirming
In the ninth chapter of Esther, “affirm” appears seven times, and “annul” also appears seven times.
Esther and Mordecai affirm the second decree as a way of annulling the first one.
From where did this strategy originate? To answer that question, we return to Mordecai’s challenge to Esther, when he first persuaded her to act (4:12-14).
Mordecai’s speech contains multiple links to a passage in Numbers chapter 30. The following features are found in both:
- A girl on the cusp of adulthood - a na’arah
- A married girl
- Guidance concerning relationship with a spouse
- Reference to “her father’s house”
- Disastrous consequences of keeping silent
- A short window of time
- A doubled verb, that is doubled only in these two passages–nowhere else in the Bible
In Esther 4:14, the word for lehacharish (silence) is only doubled in one other place: In the Numbers 30 passage about a na’arah. That passage deals with the topic of a na’arah (a girl on the cusp of adulthood), a rash vow, breaking silence during a short window of time, the ultimate consequences if the silence is not broken, and the context of “her father’s house”.
The more detailed meaning of lehacharish is “to act as if one has not heard”. The husband can “make himself deaf” to a wife’s impetuous vow–but he is still responsible for the consequences.
“her husband can affirm it; her husband can annul.”
But what does a husband’s affirming/annulling in Numbers 30 have to do with Esther? It turns out that the word “ishah”, meaning “her husband”, can also mean “a woman”, if different vowels are used. In fact, all that is needed is to remove one dot over one letter in “ishah”. (That dot “vowelizes” the word “ishah”, turning it masculine). Mordecai seems to be referencing a second, prophetic meaning to the text:
“a woman can affirm; a woman can annul.”
This is the precise position in which Esther finds herself! There will come a time when a woman will be in a position to annul her spouse’s impetuous words–a declaration that would cause extreme hardship. And that moment, Mordecai tells Esther, has come.
Now Mordecai’s words to Esther, rooted in Jewish history, make more sense. And now we are in a position to more deeply explore the meaning of “Pur”.
In Ancient Persian or Aramaic, “Pur” means “lots”. But in biblical Hebrew, “Pur” means “annul”. In Numbers 30, the Hebrew word “annul” derives from the word “Pur”.
In the end, Purim is named not for Haman’s “lots”, but for Esther’s “annulments”!
“a woman can affirm; a woman can annul”
Esther attempted to “annul” the first decree, but that strategy failed. She now shifts toward “affirming” a second decree.
Ultimately, this phrase from Numbers 30 anchors a theme prevalent throughout the whole book of Esther: a na’arah with power to annul a rash vow and rescue her loved ones from disaster.
And through not only power but genius as well, she accomplishes the annulment through a strategy of affirmation!
To take plunder, or not?
The story contains more roots in Jewish history. Rewinding for a moment back to the two days of conflict: On both days, it is recorded that the Jews “did not lay their hands on the plunder.” (9:10, 9:15)
This, even though Mordecai’s decree explicitly says the Jews could take plunder:
The king’s edict granted the Jews in every city the right … to plunder the property of their enemies. (8:11)
Why would Mordecai authorize something he knows the Jews are not going to do? And why would the author make a point of recording that in fact they did took no plunder?
Haman was an Agagite. And who was Agag? He was king of Amalek. Recall Saul’s battle with Amalek, for which the strict rule from Yahweh was: No taking of plunder from Amalek (1 Sam 15). Saul, a Benjamite, failed to obey this decree and suffered severe consequences. Mordecai, who was not only a descendant of Benjamin but also descended from Saul’s father Kish, would be keenly aware of this bit of family history. All of the Jews would have also been sensitized to the consequences of taking plunder from Amalek.
The connection with Judah, Benjamin, and Jacob
We have seen the author of Esther use the literary technique of employing a rarely used phrase to call attention to Numbers 30.
The author also uses this technique in the text where Esther is imploring her indifferent king to intercede, risking her life by revealing her intense concern for her people. Twice, the text of Esther uses language that refers back to similar phraseology in the story of Judah, Benjamin, and Jacob.
The author is saying, in effect, “To really understand what’s happening here, go and understand what’s happening there.”
“…for how could I bear to see the terrible [fate] that befalls my people…” (Esther 8:5-6)
With the exception of a single syllable, these words are a direct quote of a declaration centuries before–toward the end of Joseph’s story. Benjamin’s brother Judah pleaded with the Egyptian official for Benjamin’s safe return:
“…for how could I bear to see the terrible [fate] that befalls my father…” (Gen 44:34)
In the entire Hebrew Bible, this phrase–bera asher yimtza et–appears in only these two places.
Was Esther simply using that phrase because it sounded nice? Or was Judah’s situation uniquely meaningful to her?
This is not the only connector between these two moments in history; Esther borrows another phrase from the drama of Judah, Benjamin, and Jacob. When Mordecai first approached Esther, she responded…
“I will go to the king against the rules, and if I am lost, then so be it; I am lost.” (Esther 4:16)
Hebrew: veka’asher avadeti, avadeti.
The pattern is the word “if” (ka’asher), followed by a doubled verb. This pattern only occurs one other time: When Jacob finally decides to allow Benjamin to go to Egypt, saying:
“And if I am to lose [Benjamin], then so be it; I shall lose [him].” (Gen 43:14)
Hebrew: veka’asher shakolti, shakolti.
Children of Leah, children of Rachel
What did the author of Esther want readers to understand from the story of Judah, Jacob, and Benjamin?
Jacob’s family was literally born of rivalry–rivalry between two sisters, Leah and Rachel. Their competition for Jacob’s love would filter down through the generations. Jacob’s sons perceive that Jacob favors Joseph (son of Rachel), and they “cannot speak peacefully to him.” (Gen 37:4). This phrase will come back to us later.
When famine strikes, the brothers–except for Benjamin, the last remaining son of Jacob’s first love, Rachel–arrive in Egypt. Joseph keeps Simeon and tells the brothers to bring Benjamin when they return, or he will know they are spies. Eventually, the famine becomes so severe that Jacob is forced to allow them to return to Egypt, with Benjamin, whose safety is personally guaranteed by Judah son of Leah.
When they do return to Egypt, Joseph has Benjamin framed for theft; he resolves to keep Benjamin and let everyone else go. But Judah offers himself in Benjamin’s place, making an impassioned plea on behalf of his father, who he feared would die of grief if Benjamin did not return.
(Judah also revealed that Jacob still mourned Joseph’s absence, which was very likely the first confirmation Joseph had that Jacob had no part in Joseph’s abduction to Egypt. But that is another story).
How difficult it must have been for Judah to face the fact that his father loved Rachel’s children more than he loved Leah’s! Yet he did face it, and more than that, he put his life on the line for Benjamin.
Now, centuries later, descendants of Rachel have a chance to return the favor. Esther, descended from Benjamin, is faced with the choice of either using her influence to save her own family, or risking it all to intercede for Leah’s children–Judah’s descendants.
Long ago, Jacob risked Benjamin in sending him with Judah: veka’asher shakolti, shakolti". Now, Esther quotes Jacob almost verbatim in openly facing the possibility that “precious Benjamin” might not make it back alive: “veka’asher avadeti, avadeti”.
Judah pleaded with the Prince of Egypt in ancient times, willingly offering himself so that a child of Rachel could go free: “how could I bear to see the terrible [fate] that befalls my father…”. Now, Esther uses the same words to plead with the king of Persia, willingly risking herself so that the children of Judah may be saved: “how could I bear to see the terrible [fate] that befalls my people…">
Many other parallels can be found connecting Joseph’s story with Esther’s. (In fact, David Fohrman has a sequel to his book on his to-do list: “The literary links between Esther and the Joseph saga are breathtakingly extensive.” –The Queen You Thought You Knew, p. 120).
Conclusion
As a Christian, I strive to read the Bible frequently and “spend time with God” on a regular basis, but Esther and the Jews of her day serve in many ways as an awe-inspiring upward call, giving every indication of walking with God on an entirely different level. They pursued deep knowledge of God’s word, and followed it, all in a world that could care less about God or what he wants.
Although God is not mentioned by name, the story of Esther and her people takes place in the rich context of the Torah and the Prophets–all the way back to Abraham, Joseph, Moses, Samuel. The Jewish people not only knew their text and their family history with radical thoroughness; they lived their lives in light of that knowledge. Esther and Mordecai were only the most visible examples of Jewish devotion to God and his word.